Openminds Blogspot Saturday, September 11, 2010
  Search
 A day to remember
Location: BlogsLindsey German    
Posted by: Lindsey German 30/01/2007 14:29

The scale and methods of the Nazi genocide of Jewish people make it a politically unique event that deserves a special day of memorial.

My favourite book of the last year was Suite Francaise by Irene Nemirovsky. The two sections in the book were originally planned as the first of six interconnected stories based around the fall of France in 1940 during the Second World War and its consequences. Nemirovsky never finished them - a French Jew, she was arrested, deported and died in Auschwitz. The books were only recently discovered and published to great and justified critical acclaim.


The Holocaust casts a long shadow even into the 21st century. I was recently in Vienna where I saw Rachel Whiteread’s Holocaust memorial in the Judenplatz. Inscribed on it was the figure of 65,000 -the number of Austrian Jews who perished. In every occupied country of Europe it was the same story. Some of the most shocking and memorable art of the past 60 years has tried to come to terms with this terrible episode in human history. The novels of Primo Levi or Vassily Grossman, and films such as Au Revoir Les Enfants or Schindler’s List, show how these personal tragedies intertwined with political tragedy.


Another modern tragedy is the way in which the state of Israel, seen as a refuge for Jews worldwide after the Second World War, has become a major oppressor of Palestinians and of Arabs living within its borders. It is also the most dangerous place in the world for Jews to live. But, while we should understand why this process came about, we should never allow opposition to Israel’s policies to prevent us from seeing the significance of the Holocaust. The current debate around Holocaust Memorial Day is a case in point. The fact that the day is promoted by some who want to deny the most basic rights to the Palestinians leads some people, especially inside the Muslim communities, to refuse to mark the day. They say that all genocides and racist atrocities should be commemorated on this day, not just the Holocaust.


It is true that there have been many other terrible events which do not receive the same attention. No doubt this is partly due to an ignorance which itself comes from a Eurocentric view of the world. There may be good reasons to campaign for such events to be remembered in their own right.
But the Holocaust is unique. Six million perished in the space of a few years, sent to their deaths by a Nazi regime which had the full backing of the big corporations. The state of the art technology and the industrial production methods of modern capitalism were used to bring about an episode of the worst barbarism, with the lethal gas manufactured by big companies, and Europe’s railway system used as the fast track to extermination.


The Nazis set out to systematically destroy all opposition, which is why their first victims were trade unionists, communists and socialists. The Jews were the scapegoats of all Europe.
To treat the Holocaust as one of a number of terrible wrongs is to downgrade it. All those who oppose racism and fascism—which includes the vast majority of the Muslim communities—should remember it on that day. We should all do everything in our power to prevent anything like it ever happening again. That doesn’t mean we should give up our criticism of Israel or of its ideology, Zionism. We should continue to campaign for justice for the Palestinians, for the right of return, and for a democratic secular state where those of all religions and none can live peacefully.


There are other parallels to draw. Enlightenment Europe, whose “civilised” values Muslims are encouraged to integrate into by sanctimonious government ministers, produced much scientific, intellectual and social advance. It also produced two world wars and the Holocaust.
If there were any repeat of such a catastrophe in Europe today, the Jews, socialists, trade unionists, gays and gypsies would once again be under threat of the concentration camps. But the Muslims of Europe, scapegoated for the consequences of war and occupation, would also suffer in the way that the Jews did in the 1930s and 1940s.


So let’s remember the Holocaust not just on its special day, but by building opposition to Islamophobia - the main form of racism in Europe today.

Permalink |  Trackback

Comments (1)   Add Comment
Re: A day to remember    By tony greenstein on 05/02/2007 18:17
This article demonstrates the problem of the SWP and their politics. They are totally unable to appreciate the debate around the Holocaust which is why they attacked the showing of the play Perdition by Scottish PSC and the tour of Lenni Brenner, a Jewish author who has written about the appalling collaboration of Zionism, especially in Hungary, where they treated with Eichmann and in exchange for a train carrying 1684 of the Jewish and Zionist establishment out of the country sat on information that could have helped the 1/2 million Jews there to escape. I am referring to the Auschwitz Protocols of Rudolph Vrba and Alfred Wexler who escaped from Auschwitz in April 1944 to warn the Jews of Germany. This was a total crime which is unforgivable by the Zionist movement many of whose spokespersons were explicit in saying that the sacrifice of Jews was necessary to build their own racial state after the war.

THe Holocaust is used to justify the oppression of the Palestinians, by the Zionist movement which never fought anti-Semitism and today seeks to associate supporters of the Palestinians and anti-Zionists, including Jewish anti-Zionists, with anti-Semitism. It is this that Lindsey German glides over.

There was not better time than HMD to put on Perdition.

Lindsey German states that the Holocaust was unique. That is a truism. All acts of genocide and murder such as the Holocaust are unique. THe ZIonists say it is unique in order that no lessons can be drawn from what happened, to Jews who were for the most part anti-Zionist, because their only lesson is that Israel is justified as a refuge for Jews. Again Lindsey, a key member of the SWP Central Committee pretends this does not happen. The murder of up to 14 million Africans in the slave trade, the butchery in Rwanda, the Armenian genocide (which Zionists have been prominent in denying or playing down in line with their alliance with the Turkish regime) or what happened in Cambodia are all

[ Report This Comment ]

Comments which are deemed rude, offensive or otherwise inappropriate will be deleted by the editorial board. Please report such comments.

Your name:
Title:
Comment:
(Maximum 200 words)
Add Comment   Cancel 
  
 Profile

profile_lgerman.jpg

Lindsey German is convenor of the Stop the War Coalition, and helped organise the 2 million strong demonstration in London on February 15 2003, as well as many other events. Most recently the People's Assembly on Islamaphobia and the war on terror brought together Muslims and non-Muslims from across Britain to discuss and organise around the issue. She is a lifelong socialist and campaigner against racism and fascism and for women's rights. She has written extensively on various subjects and is completing a second book on women. In 2004 she was Respect candidate for mayor of London, and in 2005 Respect candidate for West Ham, where she came second to Labour.

http://www.stopwar.org.uk/

 Print   
 Archive
Archive
<September 2010>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293012
3456789
Monthly
January, 2007
  
 Search