Openminds Blogspot Saturday, September 04, 2010
  Search
 We shall not be moved
Location: BlogsIsmail Patel    
Posted by: Ismail Patel 30/01/2007 14:32

Tate Britain has entered the debate over the Iraq war by exhibiting placards, postcards and banners that were assembled by Brian Haw in Parliament Square, opposite the House of Commons.

Mr Haw, a devout Christian, began his round-the-clock protest in the summer of 2001 following economic sanctions against Iraq. He continues to this day. The placards he assembled began to occupy the length of Parliament Square and became more than an eyesore for the government. Attempts to evict Mr Haw and remove his visual demonstration failed and many believe the government took the drastic measure of passing legislation banning unauthorised demonstration within a square kilometre of the parliament building, in principle to silence Mr Haw.

The police were thus provided with legislative cover and in May 2006 they duly obliged the government by removing most of the placards Mr Haw had assembled. Since than, Mr Haw has been restricted to demonstrating in an area only 3 metres in length.

A former Turner prize nominee Mark Wallinger has painstakingly recreated Mr Haw's 40-metre long display of demonstration placards, which were removed by the police. His exhibition is titled State Britain and fills the stately Duveen galleries in the Tate. Mr Wallinger faithfully incorporated over 600 banners, placards, teddy bears wearing slogans, and even the curled up sticky tape used to stick the banners together. In an interview, he said, "It kept being described as an eyesore when it was in the square, I don't know what Baghdad is in comparison."

From friends to foes, Mr Haw has been described in a number of ways from a champion to being deranged. Either way, you would be hard pushed to find anyone describe him or his "work of demonstration" as art.

Some critics of the anti-war movement may accuse the Tate of providing fuel for the anti-war movement. But in reality the Tate has provided through "art" an avenue to preserve our cherished freedom of expression, which Mr Blair's government has tried to curtail. There are also greater British values at work, as Mr Haw's placards show his personal endurance and commitment to beliefs which transcend the social classes.

In effect, the sentiments of the anti-war movement today subscribed to by a significant majority of people in this country, has found a natural home in the Tate as epitomised by one of its ardent supporters. It is within reason to say when an ideology, such as the anti-war movement, as adopted by the old and young, atheists and religious, rich and poor, has in effect become a British way life and a value we cherish. Dare I say that those who are an obstacle to "our way" need to change if they wish to rule over us?

First published on www.commentisfree.guardian.co.uk

Permalink |  Trackback

Comments (4)   Add Comment
Re: We shall not be moved    By John on 31/01/2007 13:21
I visited the exhibition - quiet impressive but probably had more impact outside Parliament!

[ Report This Comment ]

Re: We shall not be moved    By Richard on 01/02/2007 12:23
The anti-war movement has achieved nothing, and these demonstrations achieve nothing, other than acting as a vent for people's furstrations. More constructive action needs to be taken, like getting MPs to make a difference in Parliament.

[ Report This Comment ]

Re: We shall not be moved    By Abdul-Wajid Khan on 01/02/2007 12:23
It is interesting that this has been taken up in the form of art - perhaps this is a reflection of an anti-war norm in society.

[ Report This Comment ]

Re: We shall not be moved    By Wajid khan on 02/02/2007 22:51
I agree with you, We shall not be moved!!!!!!!!!!

[ Report This Comment ]

Comments which are deemed rude, offensive or otherwise inappropriate will be deleted by the editorial board. Please report such comments.

Your name:
Title:
Comment:
(Maximum 200 words)
Add Comment   Cancel 
  
 Profile

profile_iapatel.jpg

Ismail Patel is the chairman and founding member of the Friends of Al-Aqsa. His other roles include: Spokesperson for the British Muslim Initiative; Senior Advisor to the Conflicts Forum, (which seeks to establish a new understanding of political Islam in the West and has a membership group spanning diplomats, academics and journalists); Director of IslamExpo; and member of the Special Advisory Board of Clear Conscience.

A graduate of the University of Manchester, he regularly contributes to discussions, debates and conferences nationally and internationally addressing peace in Palestine and other issues affecting Muslims in the UK and internationally.

He is also a regular commentator in the print and broadcast media. He has also written several books, including: Islam the Choice of Thinking Women, Madina to Jerusalem: Encounters with the Byzantine Empire, Palestine Beginner’s Guide and Virtues of Jerusalem: An Islamic Perspective. He is also the editor of bi-annual referenced journal Al-Aqsa.

 Print   
 Archive
  
 Search